Judge weighs bid to dismiss Lindsay Clancy murder charges after mistrial
publishers 38articles 46first reported 29 Oct, 18:37 UTCdeveloping since 30 Oct · 11 editions
Lindsay Clancy’s lawyers urged a Massachusetts judge on Monday to dismiss murder charges against her, arguing that a retrial after September’s mistrial would violate constitutional protections against double jeopardy. Prosecutors opposed the motion and said they intend to retry her if the case continues, although they have not decided whether to pursue the same first-degree murder charges.
Clancy, 36, has not disputed killing her three young children at their Duxbury home in 2023. Her defense says she was suffering from severe postpartum psychosis and could not control her behavior. Prosecutors acknowledge that she had mental health problems but contend that she acted deliberately and understood that her actions were wrong.
The defense argued that Judge William Sullivan should have investigated further after the jury foreperson sent notes suggesting that one juror was not following the rules. Attorney Martin Weinberg said additional questioning might have provided grounds to remove the holdout juror and allow deliberations to continue rather than declaring a mistrial.
Prosecutor Jennifer Sprague said Sullivan handled the impasse appropriately and that deeper questioning risked intruding on jury deliberations. She argued that the holdout juror did not refuse to deliberate but simply disagreed with the others.
Sullivan did not immediately rule on the dismissal request. He scheduled another hearing for November 16 and suggested that a retrial could begin in March.
HOW THIS STORY WAS MADE
Written from 8 articles, 4 with the publisher's own text; 7 independent newsrooms once syndicated copies count as one; this version written 102 h after the record first saw the story; the editor kept it as written.
- Publishers
- 38
- Source articles
- 46
- Given to the writer
- 8, 4 with the article's own text
- Independent newsrooms
- 7
- This version written
- 102 h after the record first saw the story
- Second model (editor)
- kept as written
- Publication gate
- passed
- Human review
- none
WHAT THE EDITOR DID
The second model checked the writer's draft against the same sources and published it as written.
Written by a language model from the sources above, then checked by a second model that may only cut, attribute or correct. How it works →