Judge Denies Lindsay Clancy’s Bid to Dismiss Murder Charges
publishers 42articles 44first reported 9 Nov, 20:35 UTCdeveloping since 10 Nov · 7 editions
A Massachusetts judge on Monday denied Lindsay Clancy’s request to dismiss murder charges stemming from the 2023 deaths of her three children, leaving prosecutors able to pursue a second trial after the first ended with a deadlocked jury.
Clancy’s lawyers argued that retrying her would violate constitutional protections against double jeopardy because Judge William Sullivan declared a mistrial prematurely in September. The defense contended that Sullivan should have explored alternatives involving the sole juror who favored conviction before ending deliberations.
Sullivan ruled that the jury’s deadlock created a “manifest necessity” for the mistrial and that a retrial therefore would not violate Clancy’s rights. He wrote that notes from the jury foreperson did not plausibly show that the holdout juror had refused to consider the evidence or follow the court’s instructions.
The judge also denied defense requests for records related to the juror and to question him under oath. In a separate order, Sullivan declined to impose a gag order sought by prosecutors, finding they had not shown that defense lawyers’ public statements posed a serious threat to jury selection or a future trial.
Clancy is accused of intentionally strangling Cora, 5, Dawson, 3, and Callan, eight months, at their Duxbury home in January 2023. Her lawyers have said she was suffering from severe postpartum psychosis; prosecutors contend the killings were intentional. Eleven jurors favored acquittal by reason of insanity, while one favored conviction. Prosecutors have not definitively committed to a retrial. Sullivan has indicated that a new trial could begin in March 2027, with scheduling due to be discussed on November 16.
HOW THIS STORY WAS MADE
Written from 8 articles, 3 with the publisher's own text; 7 independent newsrooms once syndicated copies count as one; this version written within the hour the record first saw the story; the editor kept it as written.
- Publishers
- 42
- Source articles
- 44
- Given to the writer
- 8, 3 with the article's own text
- Independent newsrooms
- 7
- This version written
- within the hour the record first saw the story
- Second model (editor)
- kept as written
- Publication gate
- passed
- Human review
- none
WHAT THE EDITOR DID
The second model checked the writer's draft against the same sources and published it as written.
Written by a language model from the sources above, then checked by a second model that may only cut, attribute or correct. How it works →